Hope

a few words about

Hope

In England & Wales, the criminal justice system’s struggle to prevent reoffending is evident, with 33% of adults re-convicted within a year of release. Understanding the hopes of individuals post-sentence is crucial for effective rehabilitation. The Hope study (carried out by the University of Nottingham, Penal Reform Solutions and Justice Futures), aimed to delve into the concept of hope among those on probation, probation staff, and stakeholders. By employing innovative walking and photo elicitation methods, we wanted to understand how hope influences the process of desistance and how probation services can foster hopeful, crime-free futures.

Research has shown that hope plays a significant role in individuals’ efforts to move away from offending behaviour. However, there’s a lack of understanding regarding what people on probation or recently released from prison hope to achieve from their sentences. This study aims to fill that gap by exploring how hope is understood, aspired, and operationalised within penal supervision contexts.

We wanted to:

Understand how people involved in penal supervision conceptualise hope and identify ways to measure and operationalise it effectively.

Explore how probation services can create conditions conducive to fostering hopeful, crime-free futures among their clientele.

Investigate whether enhancing hope within the criminal justice system can improve the legitimacy of sentencing and the overall effectiveness of supervision.

Drawing from previous research, we understand that hope evolves throughout an individual’s journey away from crime. Initially, hopes may be abstract, such as desiring improvement in life circumstances, while later stages may involve more concrete aspirations, like securing employment. Furthermore, the destruction of hope can lead individuals back to harmful behaviours. Therefore, understanding the dynamics of hope within the criminal justice context is critical for guiding effective interventions.

Our research process will utilise walking methodologies, facilitating discussions among individuals with lived experience, practitioners, and stakeholders. Through walking focus groups and photo elicitation techniques, participants will explore what hope means to them and how probation supervision either supports or damages their hopes.

Check out the findings below, which were launched at the House of Lords on 27th February 2024.

By engaging diverse perspectives and employing innovative research methods, our study aims to shed light on the role of hope in rehabilitation and inform practices that promote positive outcomes for individuals under supervision within the criminal justice system.

Hope in Probation:

Embracing people with lived experience to deliver meaningful research

 

Looking for inspiration and insight into the world of probation and criminal justice? Tune in to our podcast, 'Hope in Probation: Embracing People with Lived Experience to Deliver Meaningful Research.' Join us as we delve into the stories, experiences, and research that shed light on the transformative power of hope within the probation system.

Listen